How to Build a Talent Acquisition Strategy That Attracts the Right People | Nexus

Most organizations build their talent acquisition strategy backwards. A role opens, a recruiter pulls last year’s job description, someone adds a line about a great culture, and the posting goes live on the same boards as every competitor. Hundreds of applications arrive, and very few of them fit.

At Nexus, we start somewhere else. We define the story of why your organization exists, what it is like to work there, and who does their best work inside it. Then we write the posting. Our talent attraction consulting services and the work on our Solutions + Case Studies page show what that order of operations produces.

This guide explains why so many talent acquisition strategies stall, how Nexus builds one around your story, and what changes when candidates can see who you are before they apply.

Nexus works from its head office in Toronto and its studio in Sudbury, Ontario, and supports employers across 12 sectors and 40 countries. Our clients include Under Armour, McCain Foods, BMO, Loblaw, Electronic Arts, and Hydro One, along with many other large employers that compete hard for the same people.

→ Is your job posting doing all the work in your talent acquisition strategy? Talk to Nexus about building the story that should come first.

Why Does a Talent Acquisition Strategy Usually Start at the Job Posting?

Most talent teams are under pressure to fill roles now, and the talent acquisition strategy gets built around that urgency. Requisitions pile up, hiring managers chase recruiters, and the fastest visible action is to post something. Over time, that habit becomes the strategy. Here is where it tends to break down.

The posting carries the whole message. A job posting has a few hundred words to explain the role, the requirements, the pay range, and the reason to join. When nothing upstream defines that reason, the posting falls back on phrases like “fast-paced environment” and “competitive benefits.” Every employer in your sector says the same thing, so candidates skim past it.

The EVP reads like everyone else’s. Many large organizations do have an employee value proposition. It often lives in a slide deck and lists growth, flexibility, purpose, and rewards. Those are fine words, and they describe almost any company. A strong employer value proposition names something a candidate could only get from you.

Recruiters and hiring managers tell different stories. A recruiter describes the company one way on the phone screen. The hiring manager describes it another way in the interview. The career site says something else again. Candidates notice the gaps, and the best ones, who have other offers, read inconsistency as a warning sign.

Volume gets mistaken for success. A posting that draws 600 applicants looks productive. If 580 of them are a poor fit, recruiters spend their week screening instead of courting the 20 who matter. High volume with low fit is one of the most common complaints we hear from SVPs of Talent.

The promise breaks after the offer. When the message used to attract someone has no connection to what they experience in their first 90 days, they leave. Early attrition in key job families is often a talent acquisition strategy problem that shows up on the onboarding report.

Brand and HR work apart. Marketing launches a new brand or customer promise. HR keeps recruiting with last year’s language. Employees and candidates hear two versions of the company, and neither one feels true.

What Does a Talent Acquisition Strategy Without a Story Cost You?

The costs are easy to miss because they are spread across budgets. Time to fill climbs for hard roles because the right people never see a reason to move. Cost per hire rises as teams add job boards, agency fees, and paid promotion to push more volume through the same weak message. Hiring managers lose hours to interviews with candidates who should never have reached them.

The largest cost of a weak talent acquisition strategy arrives later. Every person who leaves in the first year takes their recruiting, training, and ramp-up costs with them. In retail, hospitality, and banking, where frontline teams carry the customer experience, early turnover also shows up in service scores. A talent acquisition strategy that brings in the wrong people creates work for every team that touches them afterward.

→ Are high applicant volumes and early exits draining your recruiting budget? Let’s talk about what a clearer story could change for your team.

Recruiter and hiring manager discussing a talent acquisition strategy during a one-on-one meeting

How Does Nexus Build a Talent Acquisition Strategy That Starts with Your Story?

Nexus reverses the usual order. The posting comes last, after the story, the value proposition, and the candidate experience are in place. Here is how an engagement typically runs.

Step 1. We find the story you already have

Every organization has a story. Usually it is scattered across leaders’ heads, founder anecdotes, values posters, and the reasons long-tenured people give for staying. In the first three weeks, Nexus runs interviews and focus groups with executives, recent hires, high performers, recruiters, and people who left.

We audit your career site, job postings, and social channels, and we benchmark you against the employers your candidates are also considering. The output is a clear picture of the gap between how you describe yourself and how candidates and employees actually experience you.

Step 2. We connect purpose, values, and EVP into one narrative

Next, we bring the pieces together. Your purpose explains why the organization exists. Your values describe how people work. Your EVP describes what someone gets in return for choosing you. Through our culture transformation consulting and employee and employer value proposition consulting, Nexus turns those elements into a single narrative that leaders, recruiters, and employees can all repeat. For large employers, we often build job family EVPs as well, because a store associate, a software engineer, and a mine supervisor choose you for different reasons.

Step 3. We design the candidate experience around that narrative

A story only works if candidates feel it. Nexus maps every touchpoint from first awareness through application, interview, offer, and the first day. We look at where candidates drop off, where the tone shifts, and where your process contradicts your message. A company that talks about respect for people should not send applicants six weeks of silence. We fix those moments so the experience of applying matches the brand that attracted the candidate.

Step 4. We write the job posting last

By the time we write postings, the hard thinking is done. Each posting opens with a reason to care that is specific to your organization and that job family. Requirements are cut to what actually predicts success. The voice matches your career site, your recruiters, and your leaders. Postings written this way tend to draw fewer applications from people who were never a fit and more from the people you want, because the story filters candidates before a recruiter ever does.

Step 5. We equip the people who tell the story

Recruiters and hiring managers deliver most of your talent acquisition strategy in conversation. Nexus builds talk tracks, interview guides, and short training sessions so every person in the process describes the organization the same way. When a candidate hears a consistent story from the phone screen to the final panel, trust goes up and offer acceptance tends to follow.

→ Do your recruiters, hiring managers, and career site all tell a different story? Ask Nexus how we bring them into alignment.

What Makes the Nexus Approach to Talent Acquisition Strategy Different?

Plenty of firms can help with parts of a talent acquisition strategy, but few connect the pieces. Large consultancies produce the research. Marketing agencies produce the ads. Internal teams handle the day-to-day recruiting. Nexus is built to connect all three, and a few things set the work apart.

Nexus builds what it designs. Large consulting firms often leave clients with what we call a PowerPoint and a dream. Nexus has in-house strategists, writers, designers, videographers, and animators, so the same team that shapes your story also produces the career site content, recruitment videos, and onboarding materials. Because we know we will have to execute the plan, we only recommend what can actually be built.

Nexus works inside talent and culture. Marketing agencies are strong at external brand, and some step into recruiting without understanding how talent and culture work inside a company. Our team works across purpose, values, leadership models, onboarding, and recognition. That context is what keeps a talent acquisition strategy credible once people are hired. You can see how this compares with other firms in our overview of choosing an employer branding agency.

Every shoot does several jobs. Nexus takes an asset-forward approach to storytelling. When we film employees for a talent attraction campaign, we also capture footage for onboarding, values content, and internal communications. One production day can supply a year of material for several audiences.

One story carries through the full employee lifecycle. The promise made in a job posting has to show up in orientation, leadership behavior, and recognition. Nexus designs the onboarding experience and signature moments that make the first months feel like the story candidates were sold.

Nexus is technology agnostic. We build career site content and user experiences on the platforms you already use, including Phenom and other applicant tracking and candidate relationship systems. You don’t need to replace your tech stack to change your story.

You can start small. Some clients begin with a single job family EVP or an onboarding refresh. Others engage Nexus for a full culture and talent transformation. Both paths use the same method.

→ Has a previous consultant left your team with a strategy deck and no way to activate it? See how Nexus designs and delivers the full program.

Young professionals at a career fair learning about an employer's talent acquisition strategy

How Does Nexus Put Your Story in Front of the Right Candidates?

Once the story is defined, Nexus takes it to market through HR marketing that reaches the people most likely to join and stay.

Career sites that answer why join and why stay. Your career site is often the first place a serious candidate goes after seeing a posting. Nexus writes and designs career site experiences that show the culture through employee stories, clear job family pages, and honest detail about the work.

Digital recruitment marketing beyond post and pray. Rather than waiting for applicants to find a posting, Nexus runs targeted campaigns using geographic and psychographic targeting across LinkedIn, social platforms, and digital media. We track performance across the funnel, from impressions to applications to hires. Many of our clients find that a large share of their hires come directly from these campaigns.

LinkedIn and social content that sounds like your people. Employee stories, short videos, and leader posts carry far more weight with candidates than corporate copy. We produce content your teams are proud to share.

Campus, career fairs, and early talent. Students and new graduates compare employers quickly. Nexus builds campus materials, event experiences, and early career messaging that make your story easy to grasp in a two-minute booth conversation.

Video and podcast storytelling. Our in-house production team creates recruitment videos and audio stories with a production value that holds up next to the biggest employer brands in your sector.

→ Are your recruitment campaigns reaching plenty of people but very few of the right ones? Connect with Nexus to rethink who sees your story and where.

What Results Has Nexus Delivered When the Story Comes First?

The clearest proof of this method comes from clients who put their story ahead of their tactics.

Under Armour. As Under Armour worked to rebuild its performance culture, Nexus helped the company turn its purpose into a simple system called the Armour Method. Four verbs describe what Under Armour does for athletes, and the same four describe what it does for its own people. The framework went onto the career site to answer why join and why stay, and it was designed to carry into benefits, leadership conversations, and retail training. A candidate reading a store associate posting and a designer reading a product role posting see the same promise expressed for their job.

Fairmont Hotels. Nexus helped Fairmont activate a service culture built on turning moments into memories. Around 170,000 people took part in workshops about their own stories and what the purpose meant in their roles. Fairmont moved from 13th to first in J.D. Power rankings, and the work contributed to an estimated $1 billion lift in valuation.

CIBC. During its rebrand, CIBC spent roughly $220 million on the new logo, branches, signage, and advertising. It invested about $3 million with Nexus on purpose and culture work. Employees point to the culture work as the part that changed how they show up every day. For any talent acquisition strategy, that is the lesson. The story people live inside the company is what candidates eventually hear about from the outside.

A global gold miner. One mining client began with a $50,000 project. Once leaders saw how a clear story improved engagement, the relationship grew into a $1.4 million program.

Our President and CEO Kevin Burtt has talked about why purpose in the workplace sits at the center of this work.

→ Want results like these for your own talent acquisition strategy? Ask Nexus which case study looks most like your situation.

Employer brand manager planning a talent acquisition strategy on a laptop with colleagues

How Does Nexus Measure Whether Your Talent Acquisition Strategy Is Working?

A story-first talent acquisition strategy should change numbers your leadership team already tracks. Before launch, Nexus agrees on a baseline with your talent and HR teams, then reports against it as campaigns and new experiences roll out.

The measures we watch most closely are quality of hire, time to fill for priority job families, cost per hire, offer acceptance rate, and retention at 90 days and one year. On the recruitment marketing side, we track reach, click-through, application completion, and which channels produce the people who are still there a year later. For the employee side of the story, engagement scores and eNPS show whether the promise is landing inside the business.

This matters for budget conversations too. CHROs often struggle to win funding for brand and culture work. A talent acquisition strategy tied to hard hiring and retention data gives you a business case your CEO and CFO can support, and it shows exactly where the story is paying off.

When Should You Bring Nexus into Your Talent Acquisition Strategy?

Some moments make a story-first talent acquisition strategy especially urgent.

A new CEO, CHRO, or CMO arrives. New leaders usually set a new direction within their first few months. If that vision does not reach your recruiting message, you keep hiring for the old company.

You are launching a new brand. A new logo and customer promise mean little if the people you hire cannot deliver them. Talent acquisition is where the new brand first becomes real for future employees.

You are integrating an acquisition. Two companies with two employer brands confuse candidates. Nexus helps define one story both workforces can believe.

Key job families have high attrition. If you keep refilling the same roles, the problem often sits upstream in how those roles are described and sold.

You get lots of applicants and few good ones. A clearer story filters candidates before your recruiters do.

Your onboarding is not keeping people. Nexus can refresh orientation and onboarding so new hires experience the promise that brought them in.

→ Did a new leader, rebrand, or merger just change your direction? Talk to Nexus about carrying that change into how you hire.

Which Industries Does Nexus Support with Talent Acquisition Strategy?

Nexus builds talent acquisition strategies for large and complex employers in retail, financial services, hospitality, food and consumer goods manufacturing, mining and resources, energy and utilities, technology, real estate, automotive, government, and professional services. Many of our clients have between 5,000 and 40,000 employees, multiple business units, and distributed frontline workforces.

We do our best work with strong performers that are working to move up in their category. These organizations have budget and talent but need a sharper story to compete with the market leader for the same candidates. From our Toronto head office and Sudbury studio, Nexus supports clients across Canada, the United States, and international markets.

→ Competing for talent against a bigger name in your sector? Let Nexus help you tell a story they can’t copy.

CHRO presenting a story-first talent acquisition strategy to an executive

Building a Talent Acquisition Strategy with Nexus

A job posting can only repeat what your organization already knows about itself. When that story is unclear, every channel, recruiter, and campaign works harder for weaker results. Nexus starts with your story because it makes everything after it easier.

Purpose, values, and EVP shape the candidate experience. The candidate experience shapes the posting. The posting brings in people who already believe in what you do, and onboarding keeps the promise. That is how a talent acquisition strategy produces better hires, lower early attrition, and a workforce that can deliver your brand.

→ Ready to build a talent acquisition strategy that starts with who you are? Contact the Nexus team and let’s find your story.

→ Follow Nexus on LinkedIn for more on culture, EVP, and talent attraction.

Talent Acquisition Strategy with Nexus: FAQs

What is a talent acquisition strategy, and how does Nexus define it?

A talent acquisition strategy is the long-term plan an organization uses to find, attract, hire, and keep the people it needs. Many teams treat it as sourcing and job advertising. Nexus defines it more broadly, starting with your purpose, values, and EVP, then building the candidate experience, recruitment marketing, recruiter enablement, and onboarding around that story.

How is the Nexus approach different from a recruitment agency?

Recruitment agencies fill specific roles, usually for a fee per hire. Nexus does not place candidates. We build the story, the content, and the experience that make your own recruiters and channels more effective, so you depend less on agencies over time and attract better candidates through every source.

What does Nexus deliver in a talent acquisition strategy engagement?

Deliverables usually include discovery findings, an EVP and narrative framework, job family messaging, candidate experience maps, career site content, recruitment marketing campaigns, recruitment videos, recruiter and hiring manager talk tracks, and onboarding materials. Smaller engagements may focus on one or two of these pieces.

How long does it take Nexus to build a talent acquisition strategy?

A typical engagement runs in three phases. Discovery and an employer brand audit take about three weeks. Strategy and brand development take another five weeks or so. Activation and HR marketing begin around week nine and continue for as long as campaigns run.

Does Nexus run recruitment marketing campaigns, or only plan them?

Nexus does both. Our HR marketing work includes digital recruitment marketing with geographic and psychographic targeting, social and LinkedIn content, career site builds, and campus materials. We measure results across the funnel so you can see which hires came from which campaigns.

Can Nexus work with our existing career site and applicant tracking system?

Yes. Nexus is technology agnostic. We create content and candidate experiences on the platforms you already use, including Phenom and other common career site and applicant tracking tools.

How does Nexus connect talent acquisition to onboarding and retention?

Nexus designs onboarding programs and signature moments that deliver the promise made during recruiting. When new hires experience what they were told to expect, early attrition drops and they ramp up faster. We also support leaders and buddies so the experience is consistent across teams.

How do we get started with Nexus on our talent acquisition strategy?

Most clients begin with a discovery call. We learn about your hiring priorities, hardest roles, and recent changes such as a new leader or rebrand. From there, Nexus recommends a starting point, which can be a focused project like a job family EVP or a broader program across your full talent acquisition strategy.

WE TRANSFORM CULTURES.

WE REIMAGINE THE EMPLOYEE EXPERIENCE.

NEXUS_LOGO

HEAD OFFICE

2 Berkeley Street
Suite 500
Toronto, Ontario M5A 4J5
Phone: 1.647.313.1977
Toll-free: 1.866.967.1065

STUDIO

70 Larch Street,
Sudbury, Ontario P3E 1B9
Phone: 1-705-670-1477
Toll-free: 1-888-654-0000